According to Futurism, fake AI-generated images of Hurricane Melissa went massively viral across social media platforms starting around 1am EST on October 28. The most prominent fake showed an enormous hurricane eye with birds circling safely above, but meteorologists quickly identified multiple impossible elements. Retired National Weather Service expert Rich Grumm calculated that based on the storm’s actual 10-mile-wide eye, the birds would be larger than football fields. Former Penn State meteorology professor Lee Grenci noted the birds would need to fly at altitudes above Mount Everest where air density makes flight impossible. The image spread across X, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, and Threads, earning tens of thousands of reactions, likely boosted by coordinated bot farms. Another fake showed a Jamaican hospital completely destroyed, though fact-checkers identified it had Google’s SynthID watermark.
Sponsored content — provided for informational and promotional purposes.
Why this matters
Here’s the thing – we’ve had fake disaster photos for years, but AI is making the problem exponentially worse. Before, you could usually spot the Photoshop artifacts or obvious inconsistencies. Now? These images look convincing at a glance. When someone shares a picture of a “destroyed hospital” during an actual emergency, that’s not just misinformation – it could literally cost lives. People might avoid seeking medical help because they believe a functioning facility is gone. And during a hurricane when every minute counts, that’s terrifying.
The scale problem
What’s especially clever about this particular fake is how it plays with our perception of scale. Hurricanes are so massive that most people can’t really visualize what 10 miles across actually looks like from space. So when you see an AI-generated image with birds for scale, your brain just accepts it. But as the meteorologists pointed out, the math doesn’t work. Those birds would be absolutely monstrous. It’s like that scene in previous hurricane misinformation campaigns but on steroids because the image quality is so much better.
Coordinated spread
The fact that dozens of accounts posted the exact same image at around the same time strongly suggests this wasn’t organic. We’re probably looking at coordinated bot activity designed to make the image trend. And once it hits critical mass, real people start sharing it too. They see something “jaw-dropping” and want to be part of the conversation. One person on X even claimed “This will be in meteorology textbooks” while posting both the fake and real images. The irony is painful.
What comes next
So where does this leave us? Tools like Google’s SynthID watermarks help, but they’re not perfect solutions. Platforms are struggling to keep up with the volume of AI-generated content. And honestly, most people aren’t going to run fact-checks before hitting share. The experts at Yale Climate Connections are right – this genie isn’t going back in the bottle. We’re entering an era where you can’t trust anything you see online during breaking news events. That’s a scary thought when real people’s safety is on the line.
